Shop Categories

My Account

Cheese & Meat Selections

Sort by Popularity
24 Per Page
12oz Wheel
Baby Swiss Cheese

CODE: 00100

$4.89

Heini's "Traditional Baby Swiss". Some people say that it doesn't get any better than this. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being... More →

8oz Cracker Cut
Garden Vegetable Yogurt Cheese

CODE: 00901

$3.89

0 0 1 12 75 Bunker Hill Cheese Co 1 1 86 14.0 96 800x600... More →

8oz Cracker Cut
Garlic & Herb Yogurt Cheese

CODE: 00902

$3.89

0 0 1 14 82 Bunker Hill Cheese Co 1 1 95 14.0 96 800x600... More →

8oz Cracker Cut
Jalapeño Pepper Yogurt Cheese

CODE: 00904

$3.89

0 0 1 12 73 Bunker Hill Cheese Co 1 1 84 14.0 96 800x600... More →

8oz Cracker Cut
Raw Milk Cheddar Cheese

CODE: 00700

$3.89

Heini's Raw Milk Cheese Statement Heini's Raw Milk Cheeses is produced without the processing aid known as pasteurization. Pasteurization is a... More →

8oz Cracker Cut
Colonial Cheddar Cheese

CODE: 00106

$3.89

Heini's very own "Colonial" style cheddar. Produced with 100% Amish Farm Milk. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted.... More →

8oz Cracker Cut
Farmer's Cheese

CODE: 00107

$3.89

Produced with 100% Amish Farm Milk, our old fashioned recipe makes this a favorite. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted.... More →

8oz Cracker Cut
Butter Cheese

CODE: 00103

$3.89

Heini's Butter Cheese. Some people say that it doesn't get any better than this. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted.... More →

8oz Cracker Cut
Original Flavor Yogurt Cheese

CODE: 00905

$3.89

Developed in 1970 . Smooth, mild flavor  makes this an excellent snacking cheese.  No Added Hormones & Lactose Free !  ... More →

8oz Cracker Cut
Colby Longhorn Cheese

CODE: 00105

$3.89

People call this " Country Gold ". This traditional recipe Colby Cheese will have you dreaming about your childhood.  Mild, creamy and... More →

8oz Cracker Cut
Lacey Baby Swiss

CODE: 00112

$3.89

"HEINI'S BEST SELLING CHEESE" This delicious cheese is produced using a time tested recipe, and our traditional cheese making methods! Weights... More →

8oz Cracker Cut
Bermuda Onion Cheese

CODE: 00102

$3.89

Loads of delicious Onion in a creamy Natural Cheese base. A favorite of Heini's customers for over fifty years! Weights are approximate and can... More →

Bacon Cheese

CODE: 00101

$3.89

Our smooth Colby base loaded with bits of delicious Bacon flavor! Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted.  ... More →

8oz Cracker Cut
Marble Cheese

CODE: 00113

$3.89

A creamy blend of Heini's White and Naturally Colored Colby Cheeses.  Produced with no dry milk & no added hormones! Weights are... More →

8oz Cracker Cut
Raw Milk Original Yogurt Cheese

CODE: 00701

$3.89

Heini's Raw Milk Cheese Statement Heini's Raw Milk Cheeses is produced without the processing aid known as pasteurization. Pasteurization is a... More →

1LB Bag
Sugar River Beef Sticks

CODE: 02009

$8.59

1LB Bag of Sugar River Beef Sticks

8oz Cracker Cut
Hot! Jalapeño Pepper Cheese

CODE: 00110

$3.89

Zesty Jalapeno Peppers blended into Heini's creamy White Colby base for just the right amount of zip! Weights are approximate and can vary, due to... More →

8oz Cracker Cut
Vidalia Onion Cheese

CODE: 00122

$3.89

Our delicious White Colby base loaded with sweet bits of Vidalia Onion! Great as a snack, on a sandwich, or in Macaroni & Cheese! Weights... More →

Pepperoni Sugar River Ends & Pieces

CODE: 02008

$3.59

8oz Cracker Cut
Sun Dried Tomato & Basil Yogurt Cheese

CODE: 00907

$3.89

Our creamy Yogurt Cheese base loaded  with flavorful bits of Sun Dried Tomato and aromatic Basil!   All  "6.75LB Brick(s)"... More →

8oz Cracker Cut
Milk Can Cheddar Cheese

CODE: 00114

$3.89

Authentic, Milled Cheddar produced Naturally with 100% Amish Farm Milk. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted.  ... More →

8oz Cracker Cut
YoChego "Sheep Milk"

CODE: 00909

$9.49

In the Heini's tradition of adding new and exciting cheeses to the market place we are proud to introduce the first sheep's milk cheese made using Yogurt... More →

8oz Cracker Cut
Goat Milk Yogurt Cheese

CODE: 00903

$7.99

HEINI’S Probiotic Yogurt Cheese  produced with Goat Milk from the local farm community.   Heini's Yogurt Cultured®... More →

8oz Cracker Cut
Gouda Cheese

CODE: 00109

$3.89

Heini's Gouda cheese. You won't find a better Gouda than this. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted.   Item... More →

Loading...