Amish Farm Milk Cheese

Swiss Cheese

CODE: 00121

$8.99

Amish Farm Milk "Old World Swiss" Created in Holmes County, Ohio. Hand cut from 200lb blocks. Contains No Added Hormones! Weights are... More 


Truffle Cheese

CODE: 00127

$8.99

If you love Mushrooms, this cheese will tantalize your taste buds. We use black truffle peelings and white truffle oil to give this cheese its rich flavor.... More 


Baby Swiss Cheese

CODE: 00100

$6.99

Heini's "Traditional Baby Swiss". Some people say that it doesn't get any better than this. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being... More 


Horseradish Cheese

CODE: 00126

$6.99

If you are a true horseradish lover, this cheese is for you. The potent bite of real horseradish root, from Lennon, Michigan, is soothed by the pairing... More 


Fennel Cheese

CODE: 00124

$5.99

Fennel has a fresh and delicious taste and scent, often used in Mediterranean dishes. With our creamy Monterey Jack, the fennel combines to realize a... More 


Habanero Cheese

CODE: 00125

$5.99

Our best selling specialty, this cheese is hot enough to fly off the shelves and hot enough to satisfy even the fireiest cowboy. Real orange habanero... More 


Dill Cheese

CODE: 00123

$5.99

We cannot think of many combinations more perfect than dill and our supple Jack cheese. The creamy mild Jack has a slight buttery aroma and is given a... More 


Colonial Cheddar Cheese

CODE: 00106

$5.49

Heini's very own "Colonial" style cheddar. Produced with 100% Amish Farm Milk. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted.... More 


Milk Can Cheddar Cheese

CODE: 00114

$5.49

Authentic, Milled Cheddar produced Naturally with 100% Amish Farm Milk. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted.  ... More 


Colby Longhorn Cheese

CODE: 00105

$5.49

People call this " Country Gold ". This traditional recipe Colby Cheese will have you dreaming about your childhood.  Mild, creamy and... More 


Olive & Pimiento Cheese

CODE: 00116

$5.49

"Tuscan Style" Olive & Pimento Diced green Olives and flavorful pimento bits blended into a creamy, mild cheese. Artificial Growth Hormone... More 


Marble Cheese

CODE: 00113

$5.49

A creamy blend of Heini's White and Naturally Colored Colby Cheeses.  Produced with no dry milk & no added hormones! Weights are... More 


Lacey Baby Swiss

CODE: 00112

$5.49

"HEINI'S BEST SELLING CHEESE" This delicious cheese is produced using a time tested recipe, and our traditional cheese making methods! Weights... More 


Hot! Jalapeno Pepper Cheese

CODE: 00110

$5.49

Zesty Jalapeno Peppers blended into Heini's creamy White Colby base for just the right amount of zip! Weights are approximate and can vary, due to... More 


Fiesta Jack Cheese

CODE: 00108

$5.49

Heini's creamy Marble Cheese loaded with plenty of chopped Jalapeno Peppers for a delicious, spicy treat! Weights are approximate and can vary, due... More 


Caraway Seed Cheese

CODE: 00104

$5.49

The flavor of fresh baked Rye Bread blended into a creamy mild cheese base. Great snacking cheese! Weights are approximate and can vary, due to... More 


Butter Cheese

CODE: 00103

$5.49

Heini's Butter Cheese. Some people say that it doesn't get any better than this. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted.... More 


Bermuda Onion Cheese

CODE: 00102

$5.49

Loads of delicious Onion in a creamy Natural Cheese base. A favorite of Heini's customers for over fifty years! Weights are approximate and can... More 


Farmer's Cheese

CODE: 00107

$5.49

Produced with 100% Amish Farm Milk, our old fashioned recipe makes this a favorite. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted.... More 


Sharp White Cheddar

CODE: 00119

$5.49

Heini's traditional "Milled Cheddar" aged to perfection! Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted.   Item... More 


Sharp Yellow Cheddar

CODE: 00120

$5.49

Heini's traditional "Milled Cheddar" aged to perfection! Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted.   Item... More 

Loading...