Search options Open Hide
  
 or  Reset
Vanilla Marshmallow Bits

CODE: 49004

$2.79


Crisp Vegetable Chips

CODE: 45001

$6.19


Raw Milk Cheddar Cheese

CODE: 00700

$5.99

Heini's Raw Milk Cheese Statement Heini's Raw Milk Cheeses is produced without the processing aid known as pasteurization. Pasteurization is a...


Wurstkuchl - 6.7oz
Wurstkuchl

CODE: 20008

$8.99   $6.99
-22%

SPECIAL: BUY 3 OR MORE FOR  $6.49 Each! Made in Germany Wurstkuchl Sweet and Hot Sweet Mustard www.wurstkuchlusa.com...


Country Castle Limburger Cheese - 6oz
Limburger Cheese

CODE: 01012

$6.79

Country Castle Limburger Cheese Net Wt. Approx 6oz (.38lb) Nutrition Facts: Serving Size 1oz (28g), Servings Per Container approx 16, Amount...


Lacey Baby Swiss

CODE: 00112

$5.49

"HEINI'S BEST SELLING CHEESE" This delicious cheese is produced using a time tested recipe, and our traditional cheese making methods! Weights...


Baby Swiss Cheese

CODE: 00100

$6.89

Heini's "Traditional Baby Swiss". Some people say that it doesn't get any better than this. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being...


Feta Cheese
Feta Cheese

CODE: 65000

$7.99

FETA CHEESE www.ezrasdairy.com Delicate Feta cheese in sea salt brine Artificial Growth Hormone Free, Gluten Free Store at...


Butter Cheese

CODE: 00103

$5.49

Heini's Butter Cheese. Some people say that it doesn't get any better than this. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted....


Lite Feta Cheese Cubes
Lite Feta Cheese Cubes

CODE: 65004

$7.99

LITE FETA CHEESE CUBES www.ezrasdairy.com Delicate lite Feta cheese sliced in sea salt brine Artificial Growth Hormone Free, Gluten Free...


Colby Longhorn Cheese

CODE: 00105

$5.49

People call this " Country Gold ". This traditional recipe Colby Cheese will have you dreaming about your childhood.  Mild, creamy and...


Classic Greek Yogurt
Classic Greek Yogurt

CODE: 00900

$5.45

Developed in 1970 . Smooth, mild flavor  makes this an excellent snacking cheese.  No Added Hormones & Lactose Free !  ...


Garden Vegetable Yogurt Cheese

CODE: 00901

$5.45

A crunchy combination of chopped vegetables and Heini's Original Yogurt Cheese base. Item Options: 8oz Cracker Cut, 12oz Wheel, 3LB Wheel, 6.75LB...


Original Flavor Yogurt Cheese

CODE: 00905

$5.45

Developed in 1970 . Smooth, mild flavor  makes this an excellent snacking cheese.  No Added Hormones & Lactose Free !  ...


Farmer's Cheese

CODE: 00107

$5.49

Produced with 100% Amish Farm Milk, our old fashioned recipe makes this a favorite. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted....


Colonial Cheddar Cheese

CODE: 00106

$5.49

Heini's very own "Colonial" style cheddar. Produced with 100% Amish Farm Milk. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted....


Bacon Cheese

CODE: 00101

$5.49

Our smooth Colby base loaded with bits of delicious Bacon flavor! Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted.  ...


6oz Cracker Cut
Organic Garlic & Herb Cheese

CODE: 00501

$5.89

Item Option: 6oz Cracker Cut


Raw Milk Original Yogurt Cheese
Raw Milk Original Yogurt Cheese

CODE: 00701

$5.99

Heini's Raw Milk Cheese Statement Heini's Raw Milk Cheeses is produced without the processing aid known as pasteurization. Pasteurization is a...


Bermuda Onion Cheese

CODE: 00102

$5.49

Loads of delicious Onion in a creamy Natural Cheese base. A favorite of Heini's customers for over fifty years! Weights are approximate and can...


Garlic & Herb Yogurt Cheese

CODE: 00902

$5.45

A taste of Italy! Our creamy Yogurt Cheese base loaded with flavorful bits of chopped garlic, basil and oregano. Item Options: 8oz Cracker Cut, 12oz...


Sharp White Cheddar
Sharp White Cheddar

CODE: 00119

$5.49

Heini's traditional "Milled Cheddar" aged to perfection! Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted.   Item...


Heini's Roll Butter
Heini's Roll Butter

CODE: 13000

$3.99

Heini's Country Style - Salted Roll Butter Artificial Growth Hormone Free Locally Produced Nutrition Facts: Serving Size 1...


Troyer's Genuine Trail Bologna
Trail Bologna

CODE: 03003

$10.99

Troyers Genuine Trail Bologna Net Wt. Varied Nutrition Facts: Serving Size 2oz (55g), Servings Per Container Varied, Amount Per Serving:...


Marble Cheese

CODE: 00113

$5.49

A creamy blend of Heini's White and Naturally Colored Colby Cheeses.  Produced with no dry milk & no added hormones! Weights are...


Heini's Apple Butter - 8oz
Apple Butter

CODE: 19000

$3.99

Heini's Amish-Style Apple Butter Net Wt 8oz Nutrition Facts: Serving Size 1tbsp (20g), Servings Per Container 13, Amount Per Serving:...


Swiss & Rye Process Cheese - approx 16oz (1lb)
Swiss & Rye Cheese

CODE: 00613

$8.39

Heinis Swiss & Rye Process Cheese Made with Artificial Growth Hormone Free Cheese Net Wt. Approx 16oz (1lb) Nutrition Facts:...


Rainbow Sherbet Cream Cheese Fudge - 1lb
Rainbow Sherbet Cream Cheese Fudge

CODE: 08010

$12.19

Heinis Rainbow Sherbet Cream Cheese Fudge Net Wt. 16oz (1lb) Ingredients: Fudge Mix (Brown Sugar, Non-Fat Milk, Cream, Sugar,...


3" Snowman (3353)
3" Snowman (3353)

CODE: 31010

$1.99


Sugar River Beef Sticks
Sugar River Beef Sticks

CODE: 02009

$12.99

Sugar River Beef Sticks Net Wt. 16oz (1lb) Ingredients: Beef, Salt, Spices, Dextrose, Sugar, Monosodium Glutamate, Water, Sodium...


Ben's Sweet & Hot Mustard - 8oz
Ben's Sweet & Hot

CODE: 20000

$6.99

Ben's Sweet and Hot Mustard Net Wt. 8oz Nutrition Facts: Serving Size 1tsp, Servings Per Container 45, Amount Per Serving:...


3" Snowboy w/Broom (1297)
3" Snowboy w/Broom (1297)

CODE: 31008

$1.99


3.25" Tear Ornament (1348)
3.25" Tear Ornament (1348)

CODE: 31012

$1.99


Jalapeno Pepper Yogurt Cheese

CODE: 00904

$5.45

" AWARD WINNING " Yogurt Cheese base loaded with spicy Jalapeno Peppers. Item Options: 8oz Cracker Cut, 12oz Wheel, 3LB Wheel, 6.75LB Brick...


3" Snowgirl w/Scarf (1298)
3" Snowgirl w/Scarf (1298)

CODE: 31009

$1.99


Swiss Cheese

CODE: 00121

$8.69

Amish Farm Milk "Old World Swiss" Created in Holmes County, Ohio. Hand cut from 200lb blocks. Contains No Added Hormones! Weights are...


3.25" Ornament (1367)
3.25" Ornament (1367)

CODE: 31011

$1.99


3.5" Bell (1111)
3.5" Bell (1111)

CODE: 31013

$1.99


Vidalia Onion Cheese

CODE: 00122

$5.49

Our delicious White Colby base loaded with sweet bits of Vidalia Onion! Great as a snack, on a sandwich, or in Macaroni & Cheese! Weights...


2" Star (1113)
2" Star (1113)

CODE: 31000

$1.99


Fiesta Jack Cheese

CODE: 00108

$5.49

Heini's creamy Marble Cheese loaded with plenty of chopped Jalapeno Peppers for a delicious, spicy treat! Weights are approximate and can vary, due...


Blueberry Cheesecake Cream Cheese Fudge - 1lb
Blueberry Cheesecake Cream Cheese Fudge

CODE: 08000

$12.19

Heinis Blueberry Cheesecake Cream Cheese Fudge Net Wt. 16oz (1lb) Ingredients: Fudge Mix (Brown Sugar, Non-Fat Milk Cream, Sugar,...


2.5 " Bell (1110)
2.5 " Bell (1110)

CODE: 31001

$1.99


Beer Cheese - approx .55lb
Beer Cheese

CODE: 01004

$6.29

Heinis Beer Cheese Net Wt. Approx 8.8oz (.55lb) Ingredients: Pasteurized Whole Milk, Cheese Culture, Salt, Enzymes.


Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream Cheese Fudge - 1lb
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream Cheese Fudge

CODE: 08005

$12.19

Heinis Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream Cheese Fudge Net Wt. 16oz (1lb) Ingredients: Fudge Mix (Brown Sugar, Non-Fat Milk, Cream,...


Asiago Cheese - approx .35lb
Asiago Cheese

CODE: 01000

$3.69

Heinis Asiago Cheese Net Wt. Approx 5.6oz (.35lb) Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt, Enzymes, Natamycin (To Protect...


3" Pointed Snowflake (3283)
3" Pointed Snowflake (3283)

CODE: 31006

$1.99


Sun Dried Tomato & Basil Yogurt Cheese

CODE: 00907

$5.45

Our creamy Yogurt Cheese base loaded  with flavorful bits of Sun Dried Tomato and aromatic Basil! Item Options: 8oz Cracker Cut, 6.75LB...


3" Christmas Tree (3308)
3" Christmas Tree (3308)

CODE: 31003

$1.99


Pepperoni Process Cheese - approx 16oz (1lb)
Pepperoni Cheese

CODE: 00609

$8.39

Heinis Pepperoni Process Cheese Net Wt. Approx 16oz (1lb) Ingredients: Cheese (Milk, Enzymes, Cheese Culture, Salt, Annatto), Pepperoni...


Hot! Jalapeno Pepper Cheese

CODE: 00110

$5.49

Zesty Jalapeno Peppers blended into Heini's creamy White Colby base for just the right amount of zip! Weights are approximate and can vary, due to...


Cajun Crab Cream Cheese Spread

CODE: 00301

$4.47

Heini's Cheese Spreads are loaded with flavor that you will love! This is a simple yet amazing solution for a quick party treat. You can dip your favorite...


YoChego "Sheep Milk"
YoChego "Sheep Milk"

CODE: 00909

$13.29

Item Options: 8oz Cracker Cut Weights may vary due to being hand crafted. In the Heini's tradition of adding new and exciting...


Joan of Arc Brie Cheese - approx .40lb
Brie Cheese

CODE: 01006

$6.29

Joan of Arc Brie Cheese Net Wt. Approx 5.6-7.2oz (.35-.45lb) Nutrition Facts: Serving Size 1oz (28g), Servings Per Container varied, Amount...


3.5" Candy Cane (1118)
3.5" Candy Cane (1118)

CODE: 31015

$1.99


American Cheese - approx 16oz
American Cheese

CODE: 00600

$8.39

Heinis American Process Cheese Made with Artificial Growth Hormone Free Cheese Net Wt. Approx 16oz (1lb) Nutrition Facts: Serving...


Chocolate Coconut Cream Cheese Fudge - 1lb
Chocolate Coconut Cream Cheese Fudge

CODE: 08001

$12.19

Heinis Chocolate Coconut Cream Cheese Fudge Net Wt. 16oz (1lb) Ingredients: Fudge Mix (Brown Sugar, Non-Fat Milk, Cream, Sugar,...


Kefir
Kefir

CODE: 00111

$5.49

Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted.   Item Options: 8oz Cracker Cut   Click here to take a...


Caraway Seed Cheese

CODE: 00104

$5.49

The flavor of fresh baked Rye Bread blended into a creamy mild cheese base. Great snacking cheese! Weights are approximate and can vary, due to...


Chocolate Cream Cheese Fudge - 1lb
Chocolate Cream Cheese Fudge

CODE: 08002

$12.19

Heinis Chocolate Cream Cheese Fudge Net Wt. 16oz (1lb) Ingredients: Fudge Mix (Brown Sugar, Non-Fat Milk, Cream, Sugar, Corn Syrup...


3.5" Mitten (1334)
3.5" Mitten (1334)

CODE: 31018

$1.99


Cheddar Bacon Process Cheese - approx 16oz (1lb)
Cheddar Bacon Cheese

CODE: 00602

$8.39

Heinis Cheddar Bacon Process Cheese Net Wt. Approx 16oz (1lb) Ingredients: Cheese (Milk, Enzymes, Cheese Culture, Salt,...


Apple Raisin Cream Cheese Spread

CODE: 00300

$4.05

Heini's Cheese Spreads are loaded with flavor that you will love! This is a simple yet amazing solution for a quick party treat. You can dip your favorite...


3.5" Fancy Round Ornament (1347)
3.5" Fancy Round Ornament (1347)

CODE: 31017

$1.99


3" Candle (3361)
3" Candle (3361)

CODE: 31002

$1.99


3" Cross (3320)
3" Cross (3320)

CODE: 31004

$1.99


3" Medium Snowflake (1112)
3" Medium Snowflake (1112)

CODE: 31005

$1.99


Heini's Hot Chow Chow - 8oz
Hot Chow-Chow

CODE: 21002

$4.99

Heini's Hot Chow Chow Net Wt. 8oz Nutrition Facts: Serving Size 1Tbsp (15g), Servings Per Container 16, Amount Per Serving: Calories 20,...


Cinnamon & Honey Graham Pretzels

CODE: 47003

$3.39


Heini's Farina Cream of Wheat - 32oz
Farina Cream of Wheat

CODE: 11000

$3.99

Heini's Farina Cream of Wheat Net Wt. 32oz Ingredients: Farina, Niacin, Iron, Thiamine Mononitrate, Riboflavin, Folic Acid


Sun Dried Tomato & Garlic Yogurt Cheese

CODE: 00908

$5.45

Our Creamy Yogurt Cheese base loaded with flavorful bits of Sun Dried Tomato and chopped Garlic Item Options: 8oz Cracker Cut, 6.75LB Brick...


Peach Rings
Peach Rings

CODE: 40003

$3.39


Heini's Mild Chow Chow - 8oz
Mild Chow-Chow

CODE: 21003

$4.99

Heini's Mild Chow Chow Net Wt. 8oz Nutrition Facts: Serving Size 1Tbsp (15g), Servings Per Container 16, Amount Per Serving: Calories 20,...


Lowery's Spicy Beef Sticks - 16oz
Lowrey's Beef Sticks

CODE: 02005

$22.99

Heinis Lowery's Spicy Beef Sticks Net Wt. 16oz (1lb) Ingredients: Beef, Beef Hearts, Water, Dextrose, Salt, Flavorings, Corn Syrup, Paprika,...


3" Rounded Snowflake (3282)
3" Rounded Snowflake (3282)

CODE: 31007

$1.99


Honey Beef Sticks - 16oz
Honey Beef Sticks

CODE: 02004

$14.99

Heinis Honey Beef Sticks Net Wt. 16oz (1lb) Ingredients: Beef, Water, Honey, Salt, Corn Syrup, Spices, Monosodium Glutamate, Dextrose,...


Peanut Butter Cream Cheese Fudge - 1lb
Peanut Butter Cream Cheese Fudge

CODE: 08009

$12.19

Heinis Peanut Butter Cream Cheese Fudge Net Wt. 16oz (1lb) Ingredients: Fudge Mix (Brown Sugar, Non-Fat Milk, Cream, Sugar...


Milk Can Cheddar Cheese

CODE: 00114

$5.49

Authentic, Milled Cheddar produced Naturally with 100% Amish Farm Milk. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted.  ...


.60 OZ
Bleu Cheese

CODE: 01005

$6.99

Weights may vary due to being hand crafted. ( .60 LB )


Cheddar Horseradish Cream Cheese Spread

CODE: 00302

$4.05

Heini's Cheese Spreads are loaded with flavor that you will love! This is a simple yet amazing solution for a quick party treat. You can dip your favorite...


Almond Oil
Almond Oil

CODE: 34000

$2.99

Almond Flavoring Oil for Candy, Chocolate and Baking (Almond Flavor is also known as Bitter Almond Oil)     A little goes...


3.75" Santa Face (1174)
3.75" Santa Face (1174)

CODE: 31022

$1.99


Digiorno Shredded Parmesan Cheese - .50lb
Digiorno Shredded Parmesan Cheese

CODE: 01007

$6.85

Digiorno Shredded Parmesan Cheese Net Wt. 8oz (.50lb) Nutrition Facts: Serving Size 1/4 cup (28g), Servings Per Container approx 6, Amount...


East India Sassafras Tea Bags
East India Sassafras Tea Bags

CODE: 50001

$6.99


Amaretto Flavor
Amaretto Flavor

CODE: 34001

$2.99

Amaretto Flavoring Oil for Candy, Chocolate and Baking A little goes a long way! LorAnn Flavors are three to four times the strength of water or...


4.5" Star (1082)
4.5" Star (1082)

CODE: 31032

$2.99


Mozzarella Cheese - approx 12oz
Mozzarella Cheese

CODE: 01013

$6.85

Heinis Cheese Mozzarella Cheese Net Wt. Approx 12oz (.75lb) Ingredients: Part-Skim Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt, Enzymes.


Barbeque Beef Jerky - 16oz
Barbecue Beef Jerky

CODE: 02000

$26.99

Heinis Barbeque Beef Jerkey Net Wt. 16oz (1lb) Ingredients: Beef, Sugar, Salt, Onion, Garlic, Spices, Molasses, Monosodium Glutamate,...


Cherry Sours
Cherry Sours

CODE: 42005

$3.09


Australian Black Licorice
Australian Black Licorice

CODE: 42001

$4.69


3.5" Bethlehem Star (1116)
3.5" Bethlehem Star (1116)

CODE: 31014

$1.99


Bubble Gum Flavor
Bubble Gum Flavor

CODE: 34009

$2.99


Winesburg Meats Grand Champion Summer Sausage - 12oz
Summer Sausage

CODE: 05001

$6.99

Winesburg Meats Made in Amish Country Grand Champion Summer Sausage Net Wt. 12oz Ingredients: Beef, Water, Cheese: (American Cheese...


3.5" Fancy Oval (1342)
3.5" Fancy Oval (1342)

CODE: 31016

$1.99


3.5" Snow Covered Tree (1101)
3.5" Snow Covered Tree (1101)

CODE: 31020

$1.99


Mrs. Miller's Black Raspberry Jam - 8oz
Black Raspberry Jam

CODE: 17001

$5.29

Mrs. Miller's Homemade Black Raspberry Jam Net Wt. 8oz Nutrition Facts: Serving Size 1tbsp (20g), Servings Per Container 13, Amount...

     or   Cancel